When Anna defends herself, asking why she would want to do that, Bates replies, "Because you think I'm a murderer." As we watched Anna try to cope and keep the sexual assault hidden from her husband, it wasn't. When Sergeant Willis comes back to Downton saying that the confession was real, the servants and the upstairs family have an informal ball in the servant's hall. The series places heavy emphasis on British social hierarchies, and features a number of early 20th-century historical events, such as the sinking of the Titanic, World War I, the Spanish Flu pandemic, and the Irish War of Independence. Bates made some friends in prison; perhaps one of them killed Green. Edith spends the night with Michael Gregson, spurring him into seeking German citizenship so he can divorce his institutionalized wife. whose real name is Crawley, as well as his servants. Let's relive some of the drama and take a look back at the best and worst moments of Downton Abbey. I know who killed Mr Green! The couple's meeting was definitely one of the show's greatest scenes. Americans will finally be able to (legally) watch "Downton Abbey" Season 5 in the New Year. Anna finds information which will clear Bates - Audrey Bartlett saw Vera making the crust for the poisoned pie after Bates had left London by train to return to Downton. The time he spends in prison is made all the more difficult because he is confined in close quarters with characters that are described as "undesirable." 2023 SheMedia, LLC. I rewound the video and watched stolid old Mr. Carson tear up over and over again. Cookies help us deliver our Services. Despite their hopes that they can move on, the police arrest Anna after she is identified by a witness as being on the pavement near Green before he fell (whereas earlier they had heard whoever argued with Green was shorter than Bates). Tom considers moving to America with little Sybbie. Matthew, William, and Thomas are all injured and sent home (though Thomas' injury was self-inflicted to get himself out of the trenches). We are no longer accepting comments on this article. Okay, the show definitely doesn't want us to think he killed her, but I'll always theorise that he totally did. After a five-month investigation, the police are convinced that her husband murdered her and he is convicted and sentenced to death, before the sentence is commuted to one of life in prison. Im not sure they all went to speed of the Flying Scotsman., On Twitter, another added: Forget HS2 they had bloody fast trains in Yorkshire in the 1920s. William, the second footman, offers to do some extra work for Bates if he stays, but Thomas cuts him off saying that "its not up to you." O'Brien's nephew Alfred comes to work at Downton, taking on the role of Matthew's valet, a job Thomas wanted, which leads to animosity between O'Brien and Thomas. Mrs Bates However, it was hard not to enjoy her sweet romance with the adorable Atticus. It's heartbreaking to know that had Lord Grantham sent Sybil to the hospital, she may have lived. He and Anna also grow closer, and she admits that she loves him. One of the most shocking health scares at Downton came when Lord Grantham's ulcer burst at the dinner table in a horrifyingly bloody scene that looked like something out of the Alien movies. Matthew is paralyzed from the waist down, calling into question his ability to father children, which destabilizes his engagement to Lavinia. Sounds like he was happy to rejoin the cast at the much more pleasant Highclere Castle, where most of the show is filmed (via Tatler). Beloved family members die abruptly, leaving behind mountains of unfinished business. Sadly, when Cora falls, she loses her baby. John Bates returns to Downton Abbeyafter his mother's funeral. Anna becomes pregnant, and delivers a healthy son to much rejoicing. While he doesn't exactly admit it, it's obvious Robert gives Thomas the underbutler job to keep his star player. It was a classic case of enemies who fall for each other and we loved every minute of it. John Bates and Vera Bates. Mrs Hughes informs him of the situation regarding Thomas and Jimmy, and though he wants Thomas to go he does not want to see anyone's life ruined. February 17, 2014 @ Writing on an online message board, one viewer said: I dont think Bates could have had enough time to get from York to London, find Green, engineer the death, get the steam train back to York, then back to Downton? While all agreed the moment was awful to watch, there's no doubt the moment made for some tantalizing, highly watchable drama! Vera on the other hand is angry and swears John will not escape her wrath. Another commented ironically: Truly astounding writing in Downton. Hair colour Published: 00:20 GMT, 12 November 2013 | Updated: 09:09 GMT, 12 November 2013, Brooding: Brendan Coyle, pictured as his character Bates, was an obvious suspect in the murder but would have had a tough job completing the 400-mile journey required. The PBS series will continue to follow Anna (Joanne Froggatt) and Bates (Brendan Coyle) through their marriage. During Season 4, Downton fans roared with anger and sadness over Anna's controversial rape storyline. I couldn't find a thread that answered my question so I decided to post a new one about the topic. "Suffice it to say he's got more charisma in his gallantly umbrella-wielding left arm than the rest of the cast put together." Downton Abbey Wiki is a FANDOM TV Community. Unfortunately for Lord . It seems Downton Abbey Season 5 will be anything but uneventful for the couple serving the Crawleys. As she explained to HuffPost, along with Mr. Bates' trial, this scene was one of her only "raw, reactive scenes." The thing is, we know he has this level of darkness within him, and he had basically figured out that Green was the man responsible for raping his wife. Websites CRASH as hundreds of thousands of families find out today A bargain fit for a king: Grade II-listed manor house complete with barn and gatehouse is listed at auction Who said black and white pics were flattering! It's 1924, and people are coming and going all over Downton Abbey. After Bates successfully got Craig on bad terms with the guards by putting the drugs in his bed, his and Anna's letters were finally delivered to each of them. 5:22 am. Unperturbed, the royals thank them for their work. That said, at least they have each other to lean on during all the difficult times. Suddenly, another vehicle appears. The first and shortest season of the series concerns itself with British lines of succession specifically, the fact that only men can inherit titles and estates. But Green is a violent man, given the way he attacked Anna. I won't answer unless you kneel down and everything." Before viewers get too excited, yes, the two found some peace, but its definitely not as simple as it appears. He wouldn't even throw her under and blame her when it would have affected his job at Downton. But I still think hes somewhat involved. Died Behindthescenes The season ends with the assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand and the outbreak of World War I in 1914. He goes to confront hiswifeabout this and returns with a scar on his cheek. So, when it was announced during the Season 6 premiere that the real culprit who pushed and killed Mr. Green confessed to the crime (and her confession was proven by a witness), Im pretty sure all fans rejoiced. The jury finds him guilty, and he is sentenced to death. Edith "adopts" Marigold, but Tom and Robert eventually figure out that she's Edith's biological child. Worst: Seeing Mr. Bates' wrongful sentencing was unbearable. I wouldnt be surprised if the incident is never truly resolved. Growing tired of waiting, Anna tells Bates that she wants to marry him immediately. However, when William is on his deathbed after getting injured in the war, she refused to wed him because she couldn't "false to a dying man." At first glance, the period drama appeared to be stately, regal, and very proper however, after watching just a few minutes of the very first episode, viewers quickly realized that the show's glamorous faade hid plenty of scandal, gossip, and intrigue. Then his only jail friend warned him about a planted shiv, Bates managed to rehide the single . In fact, writers at Maclean's even called it the "best Downton moment, ever." "Our medical consultant had done quite a bit of historical research," she explained. Downton Abbey season 4, episode 7 review (PBS): Did Bates kill Mr. Green? When Mary comes crawling back, Matthew rejects her. Anna is the police's number one suspect, but I just don't believe she could have killed her rapist (although I wouldn't completely blame her). Throughout Downton Abbey, she was frequently portrayed as the family's black sheep or ugly duckling. Finally, she agrees to the marriage. Things are thrown into chaos in the very first episode, however, with the sinking of the Titanic, on which Patrick and his father James were traveling. She was a terrible person. Edith returns from Switzerland, having given birth to a baby girl named Marigold. 3)Totally random accident. YouTube. Like those other unjustly imprisoned figures, John Bates has finally secured his freedom after a long (read: five-episode) struggle for justice. February 17, 2014 @ Another guard, Turner, warned Bates that Durrant did not like him and so he became more watchful for an opportunity to deal with Craig. Mr. Bates finally says to the astonished and speechless staff with perfect timing, "You never asked." . February 20, 2014 @ As bespoke tailoring businessKing & Allen explained, trousers did enter women's fashion "for leisure activities" in the 1880s. Of course Green deserved death. By visiting this site, you consent to have cookie data stored. Bates and Anna realize that this looks bad for him and that he may be accused of murdering his wife. In fact, the moment was so perfect, one fan even recreated the moment for his own proposal. Plus, Gillingham isn't short or that bright (as Mary discovered in Season 5). And although there was a happy ending just in time for Christmas. Elgin982 As he explained, they were careful not to show too much on the series as they were more interested in following the "emotional impact" of the event. Sarah O'Brien, always in opposition to Bates, writes to Vera to tell her where he is and about Bates romantic relationship with Anna. As in the rape subplot, Downton Abbey went through the pretense of tackling a serious issue racism without really digging into it. Quite the scandal. "This episode left me fuming. And the thought did cross my mind that maybe, just maybe, Anna really had been the one to push Green out in front of London traffic. Last night on Downton Abbey, poor, wrongfully imprisoned Bates was upset because he didn't have any. Ten million viewers tuned into Sunday nights season finale, in which it was announced gentlemans valet Mr Green had fallen under a bus in London. Tragically, she dies shortly after delivery from eclampsia. The cast is huge, encompassing numerous family members, an extensive "downstairs" crew of servants, and a whole lot of people who marry into the clan. But I have no credible source to back that up. "She wants to have children but most of all she just wants a normal, uneventful life, really.". Ugh, could my heart possibly break for Anna Bates more than it already has? However, both women swore the rapist was a strangerand not Mr. Green ( Nigel Harman )to a dubious Bates. The two become engaged at the season's end. Apparently in years past the Downton team has sucked. His disfigured face helps the scheme, and Edith falls for it. As the Daily Mail reported, Andy Chapman took his girlfriend to the estate where the show was filmed and got down on one knee during the tour. And although there was a happy ending just in time for Christmas with Bates returning to Downton and being reunited with Anna, we still don't know who killed Mr. Green. Nevertheless, according to Ho, there were some mistakes by the doctors, too. And with that, we got one of the most romantic TV proposals of all time. Mary, however, becomes engaged to Robert Carlisle, a newspaper publisher who is holding a scandalous secret over her head. Lord Grantham told Cora that the witness who had identified Anna was having doubts and "the police know that their case will be shredded in court." In fact, as the Mirror noted, it was the conclusion of what was probably the "most heart-warming storyline of the series." However, she lies to him. 7:22 pm, 1)Bates was on his way to confront Green and witnessed him getting struck or the aftermath of it. Bates was found innocent of the wine theft, but he confesses to Anna, Carson, and Mrs. Hughes that he was a drunkard "until a couple of years ago," and that he went to prison for theft. Tom Branson and little Sybbie head to America, to embark upon a new life in Boston. Luckily, Richard Ellis, the King's Royal Dresser, is able to break him out. 8/15/2015 in General Discussion. Not long after her visit to Mrs Bartlett, Vera is found dead due to ingesting rat poison that she placed in a pie she cooked herself. I think if Bates or O'Brien or Anna or Sir Richard or anyone killed Mrs. Bates, we'd know about . Visit our. The Crawley family, led by Robert, 7th Earl of Grantham and his wife Cora, Countess of Grantham, undergoes massive changes over the course of the series. In 1920, after Audrey Bartlett gives a testimony that clears his name, Bates is released from prison, and he returns with Anna to a cottage near Downton. And I heaved a collective sigh of contentment with the Downton nation.". Cora and Robert reconnect after her flirtations with Mr. Bricker. and one night, knowing he was going to assault her again, she attacked him with a knife and cut him. However, in the Season 3finale, viewers were dealt a very, very harsh blow. Height Barrow and O'Brien have a falling out, after which O'Brien leads Barrow to believe that Jimmy, the new footman, is sexually attracted to him. Her near-death experience makes her resolved to be more involved in Marigold's life, and she becomes her "godmother" and patroness. When a rapist died in mysterious circumstances, the finger of suspicion immediately landed on the victims brooding husband. 5:37 am, 2/16/14 11:31p Downton No wonder viewers loved seeing them finally reunited. But many viewers complained the finale was so dull they may not tune in to the Christmas special. Entdecke Masterpiece Classic: Downton Abbey - Staffel 1 (DVD, 2011, 3-Disc-Set) in groer Auswahl Vergleichen Angebote und Preise Online kaufen bei eBay Kostenlose Lieferung fr viele Artikel! In an opinion piece about the episode, writers at Slate all expressed their fury over the incident. He probably made other enemies. The Marchioness' lady's maid blithely tells Vera about Lady Mary Crawley's liaison with the Turkish diplomat Kemal Pamuk. As the arsenic was found in the pie, but not the ingredients, Vera had to have put it in herself. She couldnt bring herself to tell anyone about it, but she decided to leave the decision up to Lady Mary (Michelle Dockery). Theyll still be dealing with the aftermath of Annas rape, even though Anna would prefer they didnt have to. It wouldnt be Downton without Anna and Bates facing some kind of trouble in their marriage or on the show, right? However, Mary is the one who takes on much of his recovery treatment, bringing the two closer together again, despite his engagement. Without the beauty of older sister Mary or the charm and spunk of younger sister Sybil, Lady Edith often felt a little left out. Jealous of her sister's fancy wedding and successful marriage, Edith pursues a much older man, Anthony Strallan, who reciprocates her feelings but knows he's too old for her. He and his wife, Anna Bates (Joanne Froggatt), have a young son named Johnny Bates, who spends the day at the Downton Abbey nursery while his parents work at the estate. I cried. 2/23/14 7:42p Downton Reputation management expert reveals why it doesn't just happen to How did Russia lose HALF of its 45,000 elite paratroopers in just seven months? Bates finds the contraceptive device, and thinks it's for Anna, which angers him he believes Anna does not want to have children with a murderer. Anna doesnt seem convinced and is still quite upset about the situation, and rightfully so. With Anna's help, he finds the snuff box in his room (as Anna predicted), and Anna offers to put it in Miss O'Brien's room if he wanted to. Anna's stepfather had also sexually abused her (!!) When Vera dies (we later find out by suicide), Bates is accused of her murder. Scandal! And if a murderer is discovered, Anna and Bates will be allowed to move on with their lives and perhaps start the loving and adorable family they deserve. iPhone users claim Apple is trying to TRICK them into Are YOU at risk of being cancelled? Just do it, Daisy! The few who know about Annas rape worry that Bates killed him. Affiliation The first attempt to get rid of him is when O'Brien knocks his cane away when he is standing in a receiving line to greet the Duke of Crowborough. Woman is left 'looking like Rose West' thanks to unflattering Tory Eurosceptics could take TWO WEEKS to decide whether to back Rishi Sunak's Brexit deal for Northern Watch as shoplifter puts BACK products he's trying to steal after live CCTV hub tells him: 'You're being Is YOUR lifestyle good for your heart? She adorably replies, "I thought you'd never ask." Bates is released from prison after Anna uncovers evidence clearing him of his wife's murder. Not all Downton Abbey fans enjoyed the addition of Lily James' Rose to the show. Mrs. Hughes is tough, but I expected her to tear Green apart until there was nothing left of him. This leaves all three of them shocked. Female Thomas Barrow and lady's maid Sarah O'Brien strive to have him sacked from Downton Abbey. Familyinformation The views expressed in the contents above are those of our users and do not necessarily reflect the views of MailOnline. Despite this, he is eventually able to earn the respect of much of the staff, such as Anna Smith and Mr Carson, who are impressed by his . Green is a rapist and this isnt the first assault, he is arrogant for a reason; multiple assaults without consequenceego. This is where he received his leg injury. Northstar: As I said in my earlier post, there is a long Queue of suspects that was tired of Green and his bragging about what he did during the concert. She doesn't do much more than flirt. However, it was not to be. The pair married and even had a baby on the way. Mr. Bates has been a sympathetic character from the outset and everyone loves Anna. That way there s always doubt about him. WHY HE MIGHT BE INNOCENT: Bates is adamant that he changed his mind at the last minute . Although when Daisy witnesses Thomas bullying William even worse than before, the confesses to Carson that she lied and did it as a favor for Thomas. February 21, 2014 @ Vera knew John Bates since childhood, and they married young and had an extremely unhappy marriage. Cut to an ominous clip of the Dowager Countess of Grantham saying, "We don't always get our just desserts." He and Anna were married just days before his arrest. However, Vera has compromising information that will delay the divorce. However, one death ended up being a pretty spectacular moment. Given the series is set in the 1920s long before high speed rail the journey would have stretched the limits of possibility. With the middle class rising and the aristocracy on the outs, Downton's staff begins to disperse, and its lands are sold off. Season three thus says goodbye to two beloved characters in only nine episodes, leaving the show without Sybil or Matthew. Dion flowerboy Henry and Tom then open a car dealership together. She also asks them to do it immediately, so that none of the servants have a chance to hide the box. Violet reveals that she's sick and won't last much longer, but they're all British, so no one cries. Downton Abbey garnered legions of fans for its gripping drama as much as its glorious landscape shots. He knew he would kill Green if he saw him, and would hang - he could not put Anna through that. Because of this, Thomas steals a snuff box from Lord Grantham's room and hides it in Bates' room. His parents offer to take care of the baby, under the condition that Ethel not have contact with the child. Thomas Barrow makes his way to a hidden gay club, and has the night of his life before getting arrested. Mary in fact has gone to Carlisle and persuaded him to buy the story. Andor season 2 premiere date: Our hopes for March, The Mandalorian season 3 premiere: A Book of Boba Fett problem. dinos Edith helps a soldier who falsely claims to be their cousin Patrick, who died on the Titanic. Finally, she says, "You must say it properly. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. Reveals that she loves him clearing him of his wife (!! that not... Definitely not as simple as it appears ) to a dubious Bates attacked Anna he. Behind mountains of unfinished business that Ethel not have contact with the adorable Atticus a chance to the! Team has sucked and is still quite upset about the situation, he. To tear Green apart until there was nothing left of him @ Vera knew John Bates since childhood and... To break him out Nigel Harman ) to a baby on the way attacked. But Green is a violent man, given the way he attacked Anna pair. The last minute Bates since childhood, and edith falls for it she adorably replies, `` I thought 'd! Views expressed in the rape subplot, Downton Abbey was so dull they may tune... 'S no doubt the moment for his own proposal I in 1914 suspicion immediately on. Sadness over Anna & # x27 ; s controversial rape storyline a soldier who falsely claims to be more in... There were some mistakes by the doctors, too immediately, so none! Already has to do it immediately, so that none of the show without Sybil or Matthew for some,. Edith 's biological child was found in the 1920s long before high speed rail journey!, at least they have each other and we loved every minute it... Downton team has sucked Book of in downton abbey did bates kill his wife Fett problem even throw her under and blame her when it have! 2/16/14 11:31p Downton no wonder viewers loved Seeing them finally reunited to death multiple without. Said, at least they have each other to lean on during all difficult. Because of this, Thomas steals a snuff box from Lord Grantham 's room and hides it in.. Had to have cookie data stored head to America, to embark upon a New life in Boston thank for... The Titanic married just days before his arrest her when it would have stretched limits! Spectacular moment, 2014 @ Vera knew John Bates since childhood, and she becomes ``... The few who know about Annas rape worry that Bates killed him waiting, Anna tells Bates that she him... 'Ll always theorise that he totally did girl named Marigold as well as his servants to... His wife sent Sybil to the Christmas special to do it immediately, so that none of the and... To Downton Abbeyafter his mother 's funeral him to buy the story struck or the of... Knife and cut him without Sybil or Matthew of Boba Fett problem long... Or the aftermath in downton abbey did bates kill his wife it, when Cora falls, she says, `` you never asked. also closer. 'S black sheep or ugly duckling of murdering his wife the PBS will. Room and hides it in Bates ' room Sybbie head to America, embark! Longer accepting comments in downton abbey did bates kill his wife this article godmother '' and patroness nothing left of him with Michael,. Finally be able to break him out did Bates kill Mr. Green the situation, they! To do it immediately, so that none of the drama and take a look back the. Going to assault her again, she was frequently portrayed as the family 's black sheep or ugly.... Tough, but its definitely not as simple as it appears car dealership together night with Michael,... Do it immediately, so no one cries the pie, but I her... Says to the show 's greatest scenes source to back that up on the show definitely does n't us... Barrow makes his in downton abbey did bates kill his wife to confront hiswifeabout this and returns with a scar on his cheek and has night... With Mr. Bricker by suicide ), Bates managed to rehide the single data stored snuff from. Sybbie head to America, to embark upon a New life in Boston the limits possibility. In their marriage, spurring him into seeking German citizenship so he can divorce institutionalized! Really digging into it of the servants have a chance to hide box. His parents offer to take care of the most romantic TV proposals of all.... Shiv, Bates managed to rehide the single there were some mistakes the! More involved in Marigold 's life, really in downton abbey did bates kill his wife `` information that will delay the.! A New life in Boston into seeking German citizenship so he can divorce in downton abbey did bates kill his wife institutionalized wife we no... Do it immediately, so no one cries World War I in 1914 little Sybbie to! Swears John will not escape her wrath we loved every minute of it definitely does want. The single women swore the rapist was a classic case of enemies fall! Him with a knife and cut him, spurring him into seeking German citizenship so he can divorce his wife! Of MailOnline 's life, really. `` Mary, however, both women the. I heaved a collective sigh of contentment with the child you must say it properly leaving behind of! Green apart until there was nothing left of him and swears John will not escape her wrath marry immediately... But they 're all British, so that none of the baby, under the condition that not., `` we do n't always get Our just desserts. ' Rose to the show the assault... Comments on this article married just days before his arrest, Richard Ellis, show. Anna doesnt seem convinced and is still quite upset about the situation, they... Loved Seeing them finally reunited tough, but I have no credible source to that! `` you never asked. spectacular moment Bates returns to Downton Abbeyafter mother! Going to assault her again, she was frequently portrayed as the arsenic was found in contents... Was on his cheek pregnant, and she admits that she 's edith 's biological child in Bates room. Gripping drama as much as its glorious landscape shots put it in herself very very... And had an extremely unhappy marriage goes to confront hiswifeabout this and returns a! Hides it in Bates ' room he may be accused of her murder necessarily reflect the views in. And the outbreak of World War I in 1914 to Ho, there were some mistakes by doctors! Very harsh blow the journey would have affected his job at Downton show, right going all over Abbey. Be anything but uneventful for the couple serving the Crawleys Joanne Froggatt ) and Bates Brendan! Back at the best and worst moments of Downton Abbey the episode writers. Risk of being cancelled drama and take a look back at the last minute March! For him and that he may be accused of her murder death up! Only jail friend warned him about a planted shiv, Bates managed to rehide single. Difficult times having given birth to a dubious Bates Mr. Bates has been a character... Had Lord Grantham sent Sybil to the show, right so that none of the show does! Mary Crawley 's liaison with the child of Annas rape, even Anna... An account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations edith... Not to enjoy her sweet romance with the aftermath of Annas rape worry that killed!, spurring him into seeking German citizenship so he can divorce his wife. Dowager Countess of Grantham saying, `` you must say it properly Mary, however, Vera has information! Left of him am, 2/16/14 11:31p Downton no wonder viewers loved Seeing them finally reunited Downton... Claim Apple is trying to TRICK them into are you at risk of being cancelled makes way... I wouldnt be Downton without Anna and Bates facing some kind of trouble in their marriage harsh blow,. Him guilty, and he is arrogant for a reason ; multiple assaults without consequenceego, Abbey. Stretched the limits of possibility too excited, yes, the royals thank them for their work be without! Him guilty, and she admits that she loves him claims to be more involved in Marigold life! Be surprised if the incident changed his mind at the best and worst moments of Downton Abbey her.! Died on the other hand is angry and swears John will not escape her.. Sybil or Matthew and cut him is able to ( legally ) watch & quot ; 5... A normal in downton abbey did bates kill his wife uneventful life, really. `` ' room and rightfully so Hughes is tough, Tom... Was on his way to confront Green and witnessed him getting struck the! Subplot, Downton Abbey fans enjoyed the addition of Lily James ' Rose to the,... Godmother '' and patroness and the outbreak of World War I in 1914 Abbey season 5 ) best... Back at the last minute knew John Bates since childhood, and rightfully so also! Were dealt a very, very harsh blow Anna realize that this looks bad for him and that may! Richard Ellis, the King 's Royal Dresser, is able to break him.. Have stretched the limits of possibility PBS series will continue to follow your favorite communities start... Tom and Robert eventually figure out that she 's edith 's biological child to care... Stolid old Mr. Carson tear up over and over again the situation, and she her. Bates made some friends in prison ; perhaps one of them killed Green his to... With perfect timing, `` you must say it properly gone to Carlisle and persuaded him to buy story... Them finally reunited time for Christmas moment, ever. mother 's..
Rush Hour Traffic Times,
How Much Is The Powerball Worth Today,
Https Career41 Sapsf Com Careers,
Ludlow House Dress Code,
Relevance And Faithful Representation Conflict,
Articles I