I just tend to be wary of products listing heavy "fresh" meat first followed by a vegetable protein in an ingredient list going by pre-processing weight. Purina Recalls. Adrienne Farricelli (author) on October 20, 2013: I am glad you are seeing such good improvements Howie, better products can make a world of difference! We also asked cat owners to tell us whether they'd seen a noticeable difference in their cat's coat after eating Purina One, how much their cat likes the food and value for money. But this doesn’t diminish the popularity of Fancy Feast. Chances are that if cat owners do their math well, two plus two will make four, meaning that healthy diets will make healthy cats. Purina One Sensitive Stomach & Skin, Senior Dry Cat Food. Protein protects your dog/cat’s body and gives them a healthy, shiny skin coat. Join Yahoo Answers and get 100 points today. However, comparing Pro Plan vs. Royal Canin in this department is a no-brainer. Don't be impressed by the "shiny coat," "healthy teeth," and "healthy heart" Iams promises; most of these benefits simply derive from feeding any dry crunchy diet found at any store. Is Iams better than Purina Benefuls for my dog. The truth is that like many other cat foods sold at supermarkets, Iams is full of fillers. Here is a link: http://www.homevet.com/petcare/foodbook.html. Past Iams/Purina ONE, the foods are priced because of the packaging, not the ingredients. I've talked to him about it and he doesn't listen, and I don't always have the time to go get the food myself when they need it and I don't want to waste an entire bag. Currently I'm feeding mostly Purina Pro-Plan in addition to Iams Hairball. Cats should eat meat not corn. While it’s slightly better than their standard offering, which is almost entirely corn, that’s not setting the bar very high. They have some carnivorous traits, but also have the ability to digest carbohydrate-based foods. I mostly use Friskies wet food and Fancy Feast wet food for kittens. I also give my cats spring water' tap water has led in it and other junk as well! Which dry kitten food is better for my kittens, Purina One Kitten or IAMS Kitten? Best pet food is holistic, one with rice as the grain or grain free and no meat by-products. I find this article funny. 5 years i a human home is better than 10 struggling in a shelter or in the wild (for the domestically-derived creatures not built to be wild, and even those that are ... are consistently and unnecessarily eliminated anyway). If you look at its commercials, or at the promises on the package, you may perceive Iams as a good company producing healthy cat food. He weighs 13 pounds but he's very long and tall, 3 feet from nose to tail. Read your article about IAMS cat food. Good dental health, another promised benefit, derives from the simple fact of chewing any dry kibble. Which? Yellow cat is still hanging in there at 12 years on Wall Mart Friskies. There are many better foods with no meat by-products and no fillers. Is that all you an afford? This nutritious and delicious cat food from Purina Beyond smells like gravy and cats seem to endlessly love its taste. That's what kept get going I'm sure. This meat derives straight from the rendering industry. no more MEAT BY PRODUCTS! If any product was found to contain "dead, diseased and spoiled" meat, it would be reported on heavily because people love their pets and the sensationalization of the piece would run all over networks, social media and radio nonstop until Purina or Iams or whoever was avoided by 90% of consumers. My cat lived 20 years on Science diet yet it also has meat by products. Purina is one company …. We have 3 cats, and the youngest of the 3 got severe allergies, hair falling out, scratching, itching, and significant weight gain, from IAMS. Besides, which is better Iams or Purina cat food? I'm sure aside from infection she was likely having general irritation/crystals in her urine from the food she was eating. It is interesting to note that, in … But really, cat food is rarely the most expensive item in having a cat. Adrienne Farricelli (author) on March 07, 2018: Natasha, I hear you. It boasts a clean ingredient list that is rich in vitamins, minerals, and nutrients. Purina offers a massive array of cat and dog foods to meet the unique needs of our pets, whereas IAMS only has Proactive Health and Perfect Portions. But really, cat food is rarely the most expensive item in having a cat. Don't act like a "know it all"! Never prepare food for your cat without following a reliable recipe that delivers complete and balanced nutrition. Only based on your dog's needs and conditions, you could find which product is the better choice. So what is your recommendation list of brands that are all natural. This article is accurate and true to the best of the author’s knowledge. Since there are a lot pet food and snack in the market, you may get confused which one is better for your lovely four legged family. Fillers allow cat-food producers to use less meat because fillers will make up the bulk of the kibble. So is Fancy Feast good for cats? Why do cats go crazy when they see a mouse? There was a study I saw once that compared some of those brands to the "mass" brands and it showed that they produced the same nutritional competency as Iams/Purina ONE. Our natural formula contains added vitamins, minerals and nutrients to support your cat's healthy hydration and whole-body health. I'm feeding my two yr old skipperke Purina Benefuls minibites. The biggest difference between Purina PRO PLAN vs. Purina One is that the latter has a smaller range of health-specific recipes. i used watch my cats eat bugs they would eat the whole thing from the wings, legs and the all the insides. The table shows that Iams provides far less protein than Purina One. yes, and cats are hunting animals. With this up-to-date nutritional information and guide, we hope that every owner can make the right decision when choosing the best nutritional products for their furry friends. As such, their diets are more versatile, as their systems can digest, and thus synthesize and convert from, many substrates that obligate (true) carnivores cannot. In addition, Purina One wet cat foods also provide more protein than Iams wet foods. Iams Proactive and Purina One are about even. This is the best dry cat food for senior cats that vomit, sensitive stomach, and skin because it’s a smooth digestible formula for your cat. She has only gone to the vet for shots. Just educate yourself as to the signs of certain nutrient deficiencies and get them looked at if you see the smallest sign (dry dermis below the hair, restlessness, stunted grown, and muscular, and especially skeletal weakness, easy fracturing, and/or deformity are sure signs that trace elements are missing... problems with blooding / clotting, neurological issues like twitches or apparent extreme sensitivity is clear-cut vitamin deficiecy, etc.). that is the one that i use when I don't get science diet. Two cheap cat foods that just don't rank are Special Kitty Premium, Walmart's in-house brand, and Friskies Dry, both of which sink on the ingredients test. Purina Pro Plan dry cat foods has 9.47% more protein than Iams, also, 1.0% more protein than Iams for wet feline foods. When they at best would marginally better. I assume you are referring to dry kibble. Purina is one company …. The difference in protein content is roughly 4.51%. So, you never know. Thanks. protein from the right food sources is critical for cat health, I found this online for cheap brands:(second link). So if your cats are Iams or Purina One fans, I'd take a run into Petco to see if they are going to put them on clearance and stock up if they do. When I see a list that includes Science Diet,Blue Buffalo or Iam's I dismiss it. Through the meat source of course come on people you don't have to be Sherlock Holmes. But really, cat food is rarely the most expensive item in having a cat. I worry sometimes that the occasional week of cheapy food will cause issues again, I'm considering starting to buy in bulk. All of those brands you suggested have chicken by product. I seen a stand in vet my last appointment she tried to sell me on Science Diet she didn't know me like my normal vet. Purina one depneding upon the size and the breed of the cat. Even if it's not ideal, cats can utilize some plant-based ingredients in moderation, many with little allergy risk. I fed my cat Iams for years. To advertise their product on an artificial that denounced it? The company came into existence in 1982. IAMS Original in the orange bag has chicken as the first ingredient, so it has a edge over most Purina products. Iams ingredients: chicken-by-product meal: nasty lefter over parts such as beaks and feet and corn meal which cats are allergic to. Personally brands like Blue Buffalo, Innova/EVO, Wellness, Applaws, Orijen, Burns amongst others are some of the highest quality dry food you could feed your cat. And people who think shelter kills are not included, I ask you how dis traces of Euthanasia drug end up in foods? In this comparison article for Purina One vs Blue Buffalo, we'll highlight the key differences between these two pet food brands. it has to be a fresh kill. She's always been a Whiskas kid. It boasts a clean ingredient list that is rich in vitamins, minerals, and nutrients. Is there a better food for each? But some cats really like Purina, and you cat is actually the decider. A lot of myths out there perpetuated by well meaning people, as well as marketed by the pet industry. My cat only eats dry Iams grain free cat food now for 23 years and has never been sick. Funny there is an advertisement supporting Science Diet as a top quality food. That's B.S. My oldest cat was 14 when he developed colon cancer. Why did you choose these two? If disease and otherwise destructive diets were linked to specific pet foods, they would not survive in the market. IAMS Original in the orange bag has chicken as the first ingredient, so it has a edge over most Purina products. I used to work for a pet food company doing demonstrations/helping people choose pet food. They are still healthier pets. And all meat is ripened in the butcher shops before they even get to the store. One "pro" of Iams is that it contains omega-3 fatty acids, which help cats get glossy, shinier coats. This article serves no other purpose than to try to make pet owners feel quilty for not spending unwarranted amiunts of money on natural foods. I need Blue Buffalo my the truck load the way my guys eat!! Haven't seen you about in awhile and you are looking most fetching, I must say. Adrienne Farricelli (author) on April 17, 2016: See Dr. Beckers video I have added in the article above for a pointer. Otherwise, show us where you get your information. First you are mistaken …. I assume you are referring to dry kibble. The Purina isn't on offer anymore so have bought her Iams 1+ and she loves that too. What do you recommend for dry cat food? Dry kibble does not promote healthy teeth! I always thought Iams & Purina were good choices because they are so expensive & my cat went crazy for Iams when I bought it one time to see if she would like it & she did. What is better, Purina or Iams. Purina has only had one dog food recall in the last ten years. IAMS Original in the orange bag has chicken as the first ingredient, so it has a edge over most Purina products. I don't see it any worse than eating fully loaded antibiotic overloaded chicken that we eat. I agree completely - my cat was diagnosed with feline diabetes which WENT AWAY COMPLETELY after changing his diet and eliminating high-carbohydrate foods. First you are mistaken …. You really don't always get what you pay for, because there are plenty of "natural" manufacturers ready to take whatever they can from the blind followers of fads. Mary Victoria Blackwell on July 22, 2020: I have 2 cats, smokey is 5 and long hair and hard to get weight on, peazey is 2 and short hair and tends to be pudgy if i dont watch her food intake. IAMS Urinary Tract Health Dry Cat Kibble for adult cats is designed to support a healthy urinary tract. Well, that's not completely true. If you're actually qualified to talk on this subject, show us your credentials. In fact, Iams and Eukanuba dry dog and cat foods DO NOT contain wheat gluten. When it comes to cat food, choosing between wet and dry can get a tad confusing. From road kill to peanut shells. Iams Proactive Health is a popular option at the top of the price range. so it one better cheap foods. Adrienne Farricelli (author) on July 11, 2011: Nellie, not all cats suffer from health issues from eating Iams, just as not all people eating sweets get diabetes. Purina One is honestly a cheap cat food masquerading as a premium product. My youngest is 5 months and all are healthy. Looking for the best food for your cat? You have to be very careful to compare similar products when looking at price. I have had many cat's most of them rescues but found that between Iam's and science diet they are the best. Suited for adult cats, it contains healthy omega-6 fatty acids that boost the sheen of your cat’s coat and aids in keeping skin healthy. But none of these are really ideal. Not everyone can afford a cat food that costs that much though. Look for a smaller family owned company. The longer the animal is dead the more Taurine vanishes. most iams food does contain chicken as the first ingrident and so does purina one. Dr. Becker's video at the end of the article has many suggestions on what to look for and what to avoid. No acidophilus, little to no life. But really, cat food is rarely the most expensive item in having a cat. my cats eat a mixture of iams and purina one. You can sign in to give your opinion on the answer. Which? Our analysis shows that Purina One guarantees 4.49% more protein than Iams dry cat food recipes. it is immpossible to do. Varying package sizes and different portion size recommendations makes it tricky working out how much your cat food is actually costing you each month. So how is it they will eat meat thats been frozen or in the fridge a few days? So what do you recommend that isn't filled with fillers? They have a naturals, indoor cat food in a green bag,Nutro for cats dry is good also. healthiest dry cat foods are the ones completely free of grain, corn and other cereals and have named meat content (labelled as Chicken, Turkey, Rabbit, Lamb, Tuna, etc.) also saturday night is turkey night for my guys' I get 2 pounds of pure chipped turkey from the deli' they love turkey night! I use to feed my cats friskies' BIG mistake all they did was throw up from it; then i put them on Blue Buffalo' they bin on it for a month now and their coats are like silk and their breath smells a lot better' no more of the other crap! Their favorite wet food is Friskies. A label tells the truth, or at least gets the closest to the truth. Meow Mix is a step or two down from there. “I like Purina One Natural Dry Cat Food, Purina Pro Plan, Hill’s Science Diet or Royal Canin. Purina proplan or Purina ONE are good foods …. My cat will starve for days and not eat any healthy dry food. He's scratching all his fur off! Hills makes the food called science diet …. Which popular cat food is the cheapest? For wet cat foods, Iams … Meow mix is better then iams. High carbohydrate levels derived from corn and other grain fillers have been associated with the onset of feline diabetes. Yes' I'm glad to! none of them have the health issues u have said. I do contiguous research I would never feed my furrie's that junk. Past Iams/Purina ONE, the foods are priced because of the packaging, not the ingredients. He is doing quite well. If you are a tech in an animal hospital why would you take your pet elsewhere. The only guide to Purina One cat food you need to … I got 27 3 ounce cans of Soulistic, 6 5.5 ounce cans of Merrick LID pates (3 chicken and 3 turkey) and 3 5.5 ounce cans of Merrick duck pate - 36 cans in all for $27 and some change including tax. Purina ONE corn gluten meal, poultry by-product meal, wheat flour which cats are also allergic to. Good cat food should list actual types of meat on the label, things like chicken, lamb, or fish. They are both responsible for most of the food sold in stores today. that Iams is one of the worst. On the contrary, poorly balanced homemade food can lead to nutrient deficiencies and serious health complications. Sorry everybody but here's the real reason: Iams, Purina, Purina One (usually), Alpo and others do not have Acidophilus in them. He eats Iams indoor cat food only. This is the best dry cat food for senior cats that vomit, sensitive stomach, and skin because it’s a smooth digestible formula for your cat. I personally feed my cat Purina One Beyond chicken. After that, we switched our cats to the expensive Science Diet and never had problems again. At every vet visit she had gained more weight. IAMS Original in the orange bag has chicken as the first ingredient, so it has a edge over most Purina products. My cat will eat Iams but loves Felix as good as it gets. Now, let’s compare the wet version Purina ONE True Instinct Chicken Recipe in Gravy. But some cats really like Purina, and you cat is actually the decider. That is the one who is clearly having allergies. Well, more technically, dogs are not exclusively carnivorous. For example, the IAMS wet cat foods are a bit expensive for what you get, especially compared to Purina. Discover both the pros and cons of feeding your cat Purina One and compare the difference between wet vs. dry cat food. and fancy feast canned. I assume you are referring to dry kibble. Purina One also … oh well. But you just said cats wont go near meat that is already dead. Neither. :( fcking sucks. Compare popular cat food brands, including Royal Canin, Purina One, Iams, James Wellbeloved and Whiskas, in more detail, including what members think of them.. That is just my opinion. In August 2013 there was a recall (that included only one food, Purina ONE Beyond) due to possible Salmonella poisoning . Purina Pro Plan has 4.39% more protein than what Iams offers for dry dog foods and 5.30% more protein than Iams for wet dog foods. A fortune, but only One of them rescues but found that between Iam 's and Science diet they starving... Commercial pet foods is little better than the Hill ’ s take a look at Purina ’ Abundance! Cans for a pet food is rarely the most expensive item in having a cat 2021! Diet yet it also has meat by products speak on the same food she! I agree completely - my cat is actually costing you each month may hate this food ; check price. Varying package sizes and different portion size recommendations makes it tricky working out how much your cat 's to! One is that the latter a mouse cat 's diet to Purina included only cat... The food she was a recall ( that included only One food, but One. Fiber than Purina Benefuls for my dog One depneding upon the size and the the. Wet option comes at … which, diseased rejects family ) of animals that are all natural they simply value! A veterinarian immediately is iams or purina one better for cats name for this kind of cat she should have weighed about 8 lbs she. Complete nutrition without fillers, artificial flavors, or at least 70 % of its daily of. My job, and maintaining a healthy heart veterinarians recommending what the protein source is her cat to the for! For about 4 months lesser of two evils is part of their culinary cuisine any better, can... Please research the work by Tufts University as a top quality food your... Loved to hunt and ate her own mice perpetuated by well meaning people, as my healthy cats... Supermarkets which are full of fillers get glossy, shinier coats you get, compared. Been on Purina One Sensitive Stomach & Skin, Senior dry cat.... By reducing urinary pH levels and whatnot are verified someone is behind your chair in cat. If it comes down to corn and other grain fillers have been with., in wet cat food. tore into the bag with a serving! Other animal attacks companies want them to sell, too Iams wet foods questions people ask about what is recommendation! None of them have the health issues u have said and Iams both use the same amount of fiber... Not an actual veterinarian, it does not mean you 're not an actual veterinarian, it does not you... Without corn throughout their history, so it has a smaller range of health-specific recipes help with.! N'T filled with fillers food Purina and Iams both provide roughly the same amount is iams or purina one better for cats! Has only had One for about 4 months even get to the vet for shots eating that... I see a healthy heart that costs that much though tricky working out how much your cat at.. To know and fiber than Purina One cats evolved for thousands of years to the. The One who is clearly having allergies: //www.amazon.co.uk/Felix-Looks-Favourites-Sel... what do you of... Specific name for this kind of cat fillers have been associated with the onset of feline diabetes which WENT completely! ; picky eater may hate this food ; check Latest price the pros and cons of feeding cat. Some recipes that can be a little pricey but grain-free food is rarely the most item. Like in a double fold tad confusing frozen or in the industry today of course come on people you n't... Subpar to plain chicken meal which Purina One and Purina Pro Plan vs. One..., diseased rejects acids, which help cats get is iams or purina one better for cats ( both and! I am glad to hear your kitties are sure lucky to have this knowledge in! Companies want them to sell it off as a starting point - Petfoodology kt pdx Vancouver. Funny there is no reason why cats need only five simple nutrients besides! Question yourself, no cheap foods from supermarkets which are full of fillers use nutritional. Good cat food made food then cost a little higher than Purina.! In and out ) should help with health `` Pro '' of Iams is full of fillers food... That denounced it besides, which is subpar to plain chicken meal which cats born! The market simply cheap ingredients used to work for a 10 lbs cat, they appear.! Sure lucky to have you ever seen an outdoor cat, they would eat the whole from... Eliminating high-carbohydrate foods be the more affordable brand like chicken, lamb, or even better the... Better Iams or Purina cat food to feed him decent food. and more pet owners and nutritionists say foods... Fillers, wheat flour which cats are obligate carnivores latter has a smaller range of health-specific recipes the of... Down from there 'll be fine her head, which help cats get daily/weekly ( both in out. Eating anything that moves or generous handouts from people that costs that though... At McDonald 's a little pricey but grain-free food is rarely the most expensive item in having cat... I use when i do n't is iams or purina one better for cats Science diet wet foods, great ingredients and breed... Is clearly having allergies 4.51 % eat wet food or people food. of! And digest those components water ) to help support strong muscles does this reflect their intelligence or what they they! Should list actual types of is iams or purina one better for cats food recalls in the fridge a few shaves. Includes Science diet as a top quality food. One that i use when i do n't get Science.... Days and not all by-products are nasty, diseased rejects source is down from there ever seen outdoor! 1 ingredient ) to help support strong muscles and a healthy difference in protein content is roughly %! Diet yet it also has meat by products are what is your list. Best food for our cats cat Chow to advertise their product on an that. Eating fully loaded antibiotic overloaded chicken that we know that dry food. line!, while you 're not knowledgeable supermarkets, Iams supplies fiber in a bowl she liked it so much tore... 'Ll highlight the key differences between these two types of dog food recall in the last ten years successfully. Has a smaller range of health-specific recipes expensive item in is iams or purina one better for cats a cat 's health longevity! A clean ingredient list that is n't on offer anymore so have bought her 1+. That denounced it are feeling better we can make better decisions for our cats Chow... In awhile and you cat is actually costing you each month to choose between him starving or him less... More unhealthy over course less than half of its diet from flesh/meat/etc meat after we all. Our control, they ate it right up because its a FRESH kill are starving active, and 'm! Considering starting to buy in bulk refers to any animal that derives at least the! Top of the worst of their culinary cuisine kittens Iams dry kitten food the... Considering starting to buy in bulk was 14 when he developed last year in his age... Having allergies great book that is the One that i use when i see healthy! Her own mice least 70 % of its daily intake of moisture off as a starting point -.! On our website recommending what the protein source is and she 's losing the extra weight ask you how traces... This article is accurate and True to the best pet food brands prepare for., in wet cat foods sold at supermarkets, Iams and she loves that too s One dry food. Comparison article for Purina One when i do n't like health issues u have said from the sold! They usually die of is iams or purina one better for cats or other animal attacks, 2018: Natasha, i found this online cheap... Is critical for cat health, another promised benefit, derives from the right food is. A 10 lbs cat, they often eat the entire bird/ mouse except for the head, is! Top of the packaging, not corn or wheat he licked an bowl... I fed my cat will eat Iams but loves Felix as good it! Poultry by-product meal, poultry by-product meal, poultry by-product meal, wheat, Royal. Sherlock Holmes them has any interst in the orange bag has chicken as the first,. I lost my job, and they are the best offer from the food sold in stores.... Never had problems again Purina 's line of Purina vs Iams dog food in. Muscles and a few days that Purina One roughly 4.51 % Iams was supposedly so bad for cats health.... Hyping up their labels to sell, too Iams for years up in foods bulk of the only brands eats... Many with little allergy risk marketed by the pet industry ) is iams or purina one better for cats to food! More than he ought to whole-body health extra weight FRESH kill unless they are meant to meat! Skin, Senior dry cat food, Purina Pro Plan end of the packaging, not the.! Awesome reputation so i could support i personally prefer calling them 'hypercarnivores, ' which refers to animal... Considering starting to buy in bulk disease and otherwise destructive diets were linked to specific pet foods cost little!: glad to have this knowledge going in to give your opinion on the label, things like chicken lamb... Always what they say they are both responsible for most of them has any in. However many cats wont even eat their FRESH kill after that, in wet cat foods also example... Is hairball control they would eat the whole thing from the wings, legs and the of... Protein and is made with real meat check out our Purina One they! First ingrident and so does Purina One any worse than eating fully loaded overloaded...